Why Wilson Accuses Gatsby of Myrtle's Murder: Examining the Evidence and Motives

...

Wilson, the husband of Myrtle, believes that Gatsby killed his wife. This belief comes from various factors that have been building up in his mind since the night of the fatal accident. Wilson's empathy for his wife and his need for justice has created a sense of urgency to solve this crime. The evidence and clues surrounding the incident point towards Gatsby being the perpetrator. In this article, we will explore why Wilson believes that Gatsby killed Myrtle.

Firstly, it is essential to understand that Wilson is not accusing Gatsby solely based on his emotions. There are various pieces of evidence that support his claim. The night of the accident, Wilson had received information from Michaelis, who was an eyewitness to the hit-and-run. According to Michaelis, Gatsby's car was the one that hit Myrtle. Furthermore, Wilson had found a dog leash in Gatsby's car, which belonged to Myrtle's dog. These two pieces of evidence create a strong case against Gatsby.

Moreover, Wilson believes that Gatsby had a motive to kill Myrtle. Gatsby had been having an affair with Daisy, who was Tom's wife and Myrtle's sister. The argument between Tom and Gatsby at the Plaza Hotel had made Myrtle upset, and she had run out onto the road, leading to her death. Wilson believes that Gatsby had intentionally hit Myrtle, as he was angry and upset about the situation with Daisy.

However, some may argue that Wilson's belief is influenced by his emotions and lack of evidence. They may question how Wilson could be so sure that Gatsby was responsible for Myrtle's death. It must be noted that Wilson had been through a lot emotionally, and his judgment may have been clouded. Nonetheless, the evidence and circumstances surrounding the incident make it seem likely that Gatsby was indeed responsible for Myrtle's death.

Additionally, Wilson's empathy towards his wife cannot be ignored. He had loved Myrtle deeply and was devastated by her death. His need for justice and closure is understandable, and he believes that Gatsby must pay for his actions. Wilson's empathy towards Myrtle is evident in the way he cared for her after she had been hit. He had taken care of her and tried to make her comfortable before she had passed away. This shows how much he had loved her and the extent to which her death had affected him.

In conclusion, Wilson's belief that Gatsby killed Myrtle is not based on mere emotions. The evidence and circumstances surrounding the incident support his claim. Moreover, Wilson's empathy towards his wife and his need for justice create a sense of urgency to solve this crime. It remains to be seen whether Gatsby is indeed responsible for Myrtle's death, but the evidence and clues suggest that he is. The truth may never be known, but Wilson's quest for justice and closure is admirable.


Introduction

The Great Gatsby, a novel by F. Scott Fitzgerald, is an iconic piece of American literature that has been studied and analyzed for many years. One of the most intriguing characters in the novel is Jay Gatsby, a mysterious and wealthy man who throws extravagant parties in hopes of winning back his lost love, Daisy Buchanan. However, when Gatsby's neighbor, George Wilson, discovers that his wife Myrtle has been killed in a hit-and-run accident, he immediately blames Gatsby. But why does Wilson believe that Gatsby is responsible for Myrtle's death? In this article, we will explore the reasons why Wilson believes that Gatsby killed Myrtle.

The Relationship Between Myrtle and Gatsby

To understand why Wilson believes that Gatsby killed Myrtle, it is important to examine the relationship between Myrtle and Gatsby. Although they never interact in the novel, it is clear that Myrtle is familiar with Gatsby and his lavish lifestyle. In Chapter 2, Myrtle mentions Gatsby's name several times while she is having an affair with Tom Buchanan. She even goes as far as to say that Gatsby is a gentleman and that she knows him. This knowledge of Gatsby could be one reason why Wilson suspects him of killing Myrtle.

The Yellow Car

Another reason why Wilson believes that Gatsby killed Myrtle is because of the yellow car that was seen leaving the scene of the accident. Earlier in the novel, Gatsby is described as owning a yellow car, which he drives recklessly. When Wilson hears that a yellow car was involved in Myrtle's death, he immediately thinks of Gatsby's car. This suspicion is further reinforced when Tom Buchanan tells Wilson that the car belongs to Gatsby.

Gatsby's Disappearance

After Myrtle's death, Gatsby disappears and is not seen for several days. This sudden disappearance only adds to Wilson's belief that Gatsby is responsible for Myrtle's death. He assumes that Gatsby is trying to avoid being caught for his crime.

The Lack of Eyewitnesses

Another reason why Wilson believes that Gatsby killed Myrtle is because there were no eyewitnesses to the accident. The only description of the car that hit Myrtle was that it was yellow, which only further implicates Gatsby. If there had been another car that was yellow and seen in the area around the time of the accident, it may have alleviated some of Wilson's suspicions of Gatsby.

The Motive

One of the biggest reasons why Wilson believes that Gatsby killed Myrtle is because he had a motive. Gatsby was in love with Daisy Buchanan and was willing to do anything to win her back. When he found out that Daisy was married to Tom Buchanan, he became obsessed with winning her back. Myrtle was Tom's mistress, and Gatsby may have seen her as an obstacle in his quest to win Daisy back. Killing Myrtle may have been a way for Gatsby to eliminate this obstacle and get closer to Daisy.

Gatsby's Wealth

Another factor that contributes to Wilson's belief that Gatsby killed Myrtle is Gatsby's wealth. Gatsby is known for throwing extravagant parties and living a lavish lifestyle. To Wilson, it seems unlikely that someone with that much money would not have been involved in Myrtle's death. In his mind, Gatsby's wealth makes him an even more likely suspect.

Gatsby's Reputation

Gatsby's reputation also plays a role in Wilson's belief that he killed Myrtle. Throughout the novel, Gatsby is portrayed as a mysterious and somewhat shady character. He is rumored to have made his money through illegal means, and his past is shrouded in mystery. To Wilson, this reputation only reinforces the idea that Gatsby is capable of committing a crime like killing Myrtle.

Gatsby's Character

Wilson's belief that Gatsby killed Myrtle is also influenced by Gatsby's character. Gatsby is portrayed as a man who is willing to do anything to get what he wants, even if it means breaking the law or hurting others. This characterization makes it easier for Wilson to believe that Gatsby is capable of killing someone.

The Conclusion

In conclusion, there are several reasons why Wilson believes that Gatsby killed Myrtle. These reasons include the relationship between Myrtle and Gatsby, the yellow car, Gatsby's disappearance, the lack of eyewitnesses, the motive, Gatsby's wealth, his reputation, and his character. Although it is never explicitly stated in the novel whether or not Gatsby actually killed Myrtle, the evidence presented in the novel certainly seems to implicate him. Regardless of the truth, the accusation against Gatsby adds to the tragedy of the novel and underscores the destructive power of obsession and desire.


Understanding Wilson's Perspective:

Wilson's perspective on the death of his wife, Myrtle, is shaped by his limited knowledge of the events leading up to her demise. As the owner of a run-down garage and gas station in the desolate Valley of Ashes, Wilson is not privy to the lavish lifestyles of the wealthy individuals in West Egg and New York City. Despite his initial passivity and apathy, the sudden loss of his wife shakes him to his core, and he becomes determined to uncover the truth behind her death.

Wilson's Sorrowful Grief:

Wilson's grief is palpable throughout the novel, as he struggles to come to terms with the reality of his wife's death. Despite being fully aware of Myrtle's infidelity, Wilson still loved her deeply and was devastated by her loss. He spends countless hours trying to piece together the events leading up to her death, desperate for closure and justice.

Gatsby's Prominent Role:

Wilson's belief that Gatsby is responsible for Myrtle's death is rooted in several factors. Firstly, Myrtle had been struck by a yellow car, and Gatsby drives a yellow car. Additionally, Gatsby had been present at the party that Myrtle had attended earlier. These coincidences lead Wilson to conclude that Gatsby played a significant role in Myrtle's demise.

The Mystery Surrounding The Accident:

Wilson's limited resources and inability to investigate the matter thoroughly leave him at a disadvantage when it comes to solving the mystery surrounding Myrtle's death. He must rely on incomplete information and draw conclusions based on speculation, further adding to his frustration and sorrow.

Gatsby's Shady Past:

Wilson's suspicions about Gatsby are further strengthened by the fact that Gatsby is not entirely honest about his past. Gatsby is elusive and does not provide concrete information about himself or the source of his wealth. Wilson's belief that Gatsby is involved in Myrtle's death is compounded by his mistrust of Gatsby's character.

The Overarching Theme of The Novel:

The Great Gatsby is a novel that examines the concept of the American Dream and the destructive nature of wealthy individuals' vanity. The novel highlights the significance of class and societal status, ultimately culminating in a tragic end.

The Dangers of Pursuing Wealth:

The novel portrays the dangers and destruction that come with the relentless pursuit of wealth. Gatsby is a prime example of this, as his pursuit of becoming rich and winning Daisy's love results in the loss of his life. The novel warns readers of the destructive nature of greed and obsession.

The Impossibility of Achieving The American Dream:

Fitzgerald's novel conveys the impossibility of attaining the American Dream for those who seek it. The wealthy individuals in the novel are portrayed as unhappy despite their grand lifestyles. The novel emphasizes the importance of finding happiness and contentment outside of material possessions.

The Tragic Conclusion:

The Great Gatsby ends on a tragic note, with the death of both Gatsby and Wilson. The death of each character highlights the destructive and dangerous nature of the pursuit of wealth and societal status. The novel serves as a cautionary tale for readers.

A Tale of Greed, Loss, and Tragedy:

Wilson's perspective on Gatsby's involvement in Myrtle's death helps us to understand the tragic ramifications of greed, loss, and obsession. The Great Gatsby is a timeless classic that continuously reminds us of the destructive nature of pursuing our desires without concern for the consequences. The novel remains relevant today, serving as a warning against the dangers of unchecked ambition and materialism.

Wilson’s Belief: Gatsby Killed Myrtle

The Story of Wilson and Myrtle

Wilson and Myrtle were a married couple who owned a run-down garage in the Valley of Ashes. Myrtle was a woman who yearned for a life of luxury, which she believed she could attain by having an affair with Tom Buchanan, a wealthy man from East Egg.

One day, Wilson realized that his wife was having an affair, and he became distraught. He loved Myrtle and wanted her to be faithful to him, but she continued seeing Tom behind his back.

The Tragic Accident

One fateful day, Myrtle was hit by a car and killed. The car that hit her belonged to Gatsby, a man who was in love with Daisy Buchanan, Tom’s wife.

Tom told Wilson that the car belonged to Gatsby, which led Wilson to believe that Gatsby was the one who killed Myrtle.

Why Does Wilson Believe That Gatsby Killed Myrtle?

There are a few reasons why Wilson believes that Gatsby killed Myrtle:

  1. Tom told Wilson that the car belonged to Gatsby.
  2. Gatsby was known for throwing extravagant parties and was seen driving his car around town often.
  3. Wilson knew that Myrtle was having an affair with a man from East Egg, and Gatsby was from East Egg.
  4. Wilson was desperate for answers and needed someone to blame for his wife’s death.

Overall, Wilson’s belief that Gatsby killed Myrtle was fueled by a combination of circumstantial evidence and his own emotional turmoil.

As an empathic narrator, it is clear that Wilson was in a state of shock and emotional distress after losing his wife. He needed someone to blame for her death, and Gatsby became the scapegoat. While there may have been some evidence that pointed to Gatsby’s involvement in Myrtle’s death, it is also possible that Wilson’s belief was clouded by his own pain and suffering.

It is important to remember that each character in The Great Gatsby has their own motivations and desires, and their actions are often influenced by their emotions and personal circumstances.

Keywords:

  • Wilson
  • Myrtle
  • Gatsby
  • Tom Buchanan
  • Daisy Buchanan
  • Valley of Ashes
  • Affair
  • Car Accident
  • Scapegoat

Wilson's Belief That Gatsby Killed Myrtle: An Empathic Perspective

Thank you for taking the time to read this article on Wilson's belief that Gatsby killed Myrtle. I hope that it has provided you with a deeper understanding of the events that took place in F. Scott Fitzgerald's novel, The Great Gatsby. Throughout this article, we have explored the various reasons why Wilson came to believe that Gatsby was responsible for Myrtle's death.

Firstly, we looked at the character traits of both Gatsby and Wilson. We learned that Gatsby was a man of wealth and privilege who had a reputation for throwing lavish parties. On the other hand, Wilson was a simple man who lived and worked in the Valley of Ashes. These differences in their social status played a significant role in Wilson's belief that Gatsby was responsible for Myrtle's death.

We also examined the events leading up to Myrtle's death. We saw how Gatsby's car was involved in the accident, and how Wilson found the car outside of his garage. The fact that the car belonged to Gatsby, coupled with the fact that Myrtle had been having an affair with him, led Wilson to believe that Gatsby was responsible for her death.

Furthermore, we explored the themes of love, betrayal, and societal norms that are prevalent in The Great Gatsby. These themes helped us to understand the motivations behind the characters' actions and how they contributed to Wilson's belief that Gatsby was responsible for Myrtle's death.

It is important to note that Wilson's belief was not based on concrete evidence. Instead, it was based on circumstantial evidence and his own personal biases. We saw how his grief and anger over Myrtle's death led him to seek out someone to blame, and how Gatsby became the target of his anger.

As we conclude this article, I want to reiterate the importance of empathy and understanding when it comes to interpreting literature. It is essential to view the characters and events through a lens of empathy, to understand their motivations and actions, and to appreciate the complexity of human nature.

In conclusion, Wilson's belief that Gatsby killed Myrtle was based on a combination of circumstantial evidence, personal biases, and societal norms. While we may never know for sure what happened on that fateful night, it is essential to approach the novel with an empathic perspective and to appreciate the complexities of the characters and their actions.

Thank you once again for reading this article, and I hope that it has provided you with a deeper understanding of The Great Gatsby and the themes that are explored within it.


Why Does Wilson Believe That Gatsby Killed Myrtle?

Who is Wilson?

Wilson is the husband of Myrtle Wilson, who happens to be the mistress of Tom Buchanan. He is a simple man who owns a gas station in the Valley of Ashes.

What Happened to Myrtle?

Myrtle was killed in a hit-and-run accident, and her body was left on the side of the road. The car that hit her was initially thought to be Gatsby's car.

Why Does Wilson Believe That Gatsby Killed Myrtle?

Wilson believes that Gatsby killed Myrtle because he found a yellow car that matched the description of the one that hit her. He also learned from Tom that Gatsby owned a similar car. Moreover, Myrtle had been talking about Gatsby before she died, which made Wilson believe that Gatsby might have been involved in her death.

What is the Empathic Voice and Tone?

The empathic voice and tone convey an understanding of the emotions and experiences of the people involved in the situation. It is important to acknowledge Wilson's pain and grief over the loss of his wife, as well as his frustration and anger towards the person he believes to be responsible for her death.

How Can We Address Wilson's Concerns?

  1. Investigation - A thorough investigation can be conducted to determine the actual cause of Myrtle's death. This will help clear Gatsby's name if he is not responsible for the accident.
  2. Communication - Effective communication can be established with Wilson to understand his concerns and provide him with updates on the investigation. This will help ease his anxiety and grief.
  3. Compassion - Showing compassion towards Wilson and his family can help them cope with the loss of Myrtle and the stress of the situation.

In conclusion, Wilson believes that Gatsby killed Myrtle because of the evidence and information he has gathered. However, it is important to investigate the matter thoroughly to determine the actual cause of her death. In doing so, we can address Wilson's concerns, show compassion towards him and his family, and ensure that justice is served.